Understanding Momentum Transfer from Light to Electrons in a Metal Film

This section reports on experiments that challenge our fundamental understanding of light-matter interaction, namely the momentum transfer from photons to electrons in metal films. 

The work is a collaboration with the group of Dr. Henri J. Lezec at NIST.

Physical Review Letters, 2019Revisiting the photon-drag effect in metal films

This paper revisits the photon-drag effect in metal films, specifically gold, and demonstrates that the sign and magnitude of the detected signal for p-polarized light are strongly influenced by adsorbed molecules, such as water, on the metal surface. The findings challenge the conventional understanding of photon momentum transfer, showing that the intrinsic photon-drag current in a pristine vacuum environment flows counterintuitively opposite to the expected direction.

[ Download paper ]

Relevance

The photon-drag effect, which generates a rectified current in metals due to light’s momentum transfer, has been conventionally understood within the Drude model, where free electrons in a metal film directly receive photon momentum. This study revisits the effect in smooth gold films under controlled vacuum and air environments, revealing that the sign of the measured photocurrent depends on the presence of surface adsorbates. Contrary to previous interpretations, intrinsic photon drag in gold results in electron flow opposite to the expected direction, indicating a more complex momentum transfer mechanism than direct transfer to free electrons. This finding necessitates a re-evaluation of prior photon-drag experiments conducted in ambient conditions and suggests new optoelectronic applications for molecular sensing on metal surfaces. By offering a refined understanding of momentum transfer in light-metal interactions, the study has significant implications for fields such as plasmonics, optoelectronics, and nanophotonic device engineering.

Main Advantages and Breakthroughs
  1. Reinterpretation of Previous Results: The study demonstrates that prior photon-drag measurements in ambient air may have been misinterpreted due to the influence of surface adsorbates.
  2. Environmental Dependence of Photon Drag: Unlike previous models, this work highlights how molecular adsorption can drastically alter the observed effect, paving the way for ultra-sensitive molecular sensing applications.
  3. Counterintuitive Current Flow: The observation that intrinsic photon-drag currents in gold flow opposite to classical expectations challenges the existing theoretical framework of light-momentum transfer.
  4. Controlled Experimental Conditions: The study employs a vacuum chamber to isolate intrinsic photon-drag effects from environmental contamination, allowing for a more accurate characterization.
  5. Potential for Optoelectronic Applications: The results suggest new possibilities for integrating photon-drag-based detection mechanisms into high-speed optoelectronic devices.
  6. Fundamental Contributions to Light-Matter Interaction: By identifying discrepancies in photon-drag sign conventions, this work refines our understanding of electromagnetic momentum exchange at nanoscales.
Main Findings & Impact

Intrinsic Photon-Drag Effect in Gold Films
The study carefully isolates the intrinsic photon-drag effect by conducting experiments in vacuum and comparing them with those performed in ambient air. In a vacuum, the photocurrent follows a consistent pattern where the electron flow is unexpectedly antiparallel to the expected momentum transfer direction. This contradicts the widely accepted assumption that photons impart their momentum directly to free electrons, highlighting the need for a deeper theoretical framework to describe this interaction.

Influence of Adsorbed Molecules on Photon Drag
One of the most striking findings is that the photon-drag signal measured in air is significantly altered by surface adsorbates, likely water molecules. These adsorbates create an extrinsic effect that reverses the sign of the observed current, making prior air-based experiments unreliable. The ability to detect such small changes in surface chemistry through the photon-drag effect suggests new applications in molecular sensing and surface characterization techniques.

Reassessment of Prior Experimental Data
Given that most previous studies of the photon-drag effect in metals were conducted in ambient conditions, this work necessitates a critical reassessment of past findings. If surface contaminants influenced those results, the prevailing understanding of momentum transfer in metals must be revised. This study lays the groundwork for more controlled future experiments and calls for a reconsideration of device designs based on photon-drag principles.

New Insights into Optoelectronic Detection Mechanisms
The research uncovers novel aspects of optoelectronic detection, particularly in the context of plasmonic and nanophotonic systems. The environmentally sensitive nature of photon drag suggests potential for next-generation optoelectronic sensors that operate by detecting changes in surface composition. Such sensors could be used for ultra-sensitive gas detection, humidity monitoring, and even biomedical applications.

Implications for Theoretical Models of Radiation Pressure
The finding that photon-drag-induced electron flow opposes classical momentum transfer expectations raises fundamental questions about the microscopic mechanisms of radiation pressure in metals. While classical electrodynamics predicts that momentum transfer should induce electron flow in a straightforward manner, this study suggests a more complex interplay involving screening effects, boundary conditions, and possibly new rectification mechanisms. The work encourages theoretical physicists to revisit the Drude model in the context of optoelectronic effects.

Summary & Future Outlook

This study provides groundbreaking insights into the photon-drag effect, demonstrating that environmental factors significantly impact the observed electrical response of gold films. The key revelation that intrinsic photon-drag currents flow counterintuitively opposite to expected momentum transfer necessitates a re-evaluation of past experiments and existing theoretical models. Additionally, the work introduces a novel pathway for molecular sensing based on optoelectronic rectification, expanding the potential applications of this effect beyond fundamental physics.

Looking forward, future studies should focus on extending these findings to other metals and nanostructured surfaces to determine whether similar environmental dependencies exist. The development of advanced theoretical models incorporating quantum mechanical and surface chemistry effects will be crucial to fully understanding the observed phenomena. Furthermore, applying these insights to design high-speed optoelectronic detectors and chemical sensors could open new frontiers in nanophotonic device engineering.